Top 5 U.S. Open Cup Upsets in the Last 10 Years


With the 2005 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup entering the fourth round on August 3, and with one Major League Soccer team already out of the competition, we have uncovered the biggest upsets in the tournament since MLS joined the competition in 1996.

Before Major League Soccer entered the U.S. Open Cup in 1996, the last time that a team from a first-division league in the United States competed in the U.S. Open Cup was way back in 1966, when the Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals of the ASL won the Open Cup.

The biggest shocker of the 2005 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup so far has to be the Des Moines Menace, a Premier Development League side, hammering the Atlanta Silverbacks 5-1 in Atlanta. Also in the third round, the Minnesota Thunder of United Soccer League shook up the bracket by knocking out one of the new Major League Soccer expansion franchises, Real Salt Lake, in a 10-goal thriller, 6-4.

In 1999, the Rochester Raging Rhinos knocked off the defending U.S. Open Cup Champion Chicago Fire 1-0 in the third round en route to winning their first U.S. Open Cup title. In one of the most impressive U.S. Open Cup title runs ever, the Rhinos earned victories over four MLS teams (the Fire, the Dallas Burn, the Columbus Crew and the Colorado Rapids).

Rochester is the only non Major League Soccer franchise to appear in the final since 1996, accomplishing that feat twice (1996 & 1999).

Lets have a look at our top five upsets since 1996 …
5. August 4, 1999 - Third Round
Charleston Battery (A-League) 4, D.C. United (MLS) 3 (OT)

The Battery shocked the American soccer world in a thrilling 4-3 comeback victory over the 1999 MLS Cup Champion D.C. United in the third round. D.C. United did not field their strongest team, but the Battery took full advantage of that and knocked off the three-time MLS Champion.

4. June 14, 2000 - Second Round
Chicago Sockers (PDL) 0, Kansas City Wizards (MLS) 0  (7:6 penalties)

The Chicago Sockers of the Premier Development League shutdown the Wizards and eventually advanced on penalties over the soon-to-be MLS Cup Champions. The Wizards held a 23-8 advantage in shots in the game, but it was Chicago that used a 7-6 edge in the eight round penalty kick shutout to advance to the third round. It was Chicago’s first-ever match against an MLS opponent.

Penalty kick scoring:
Sockers - Costa (goal), Lara (goal), Collins (save), Regan (goal), Carver (goal), Wilson (goal), Bobo (goal), Baker (goal).
Wizards - Preki (goal), Vermes (goal), Brown (wide left) Zavagnin (goal), Klein (goal), Glasgow (goal), Henderson (goal), Okafor (save).

3. June 27, 2001 - Second Round
Charleston Battery (A-League) 4, MetroStars (MLS) 1

The Battery took it to the MetroStars as they scored four second half goals on their way to a convincing 4-1 victory. Gilbert Jean-Baptiste, Paul Conway (who played at Hartwick College), Brian Piesner and Mac Cozier all found the net against the MetroStars and goalkeeper Tim Howard (who now plays for Manchester United in England) in the onslaught. This match would also mark the final U.S. Open Cup contest of 2005 Hall of Fame inductee
Tab Ramos.

2. August 6, 2003 - Fourth Round
Wilmington Hammerheads (USL-PSL) 4, Dallas Burn (MLS) 1

The Hammerheads pulled off the greatest upset in the 2004 tournament when they trounced the Dallas Burn 4-1 in the fourth round. The Hammerheads are in the USL Premier Soccer League, the third division of American soccer, and most of the players on that team played soccer part-time and worked fulltime.

1. September 14, 1999 - Final
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 2, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 0

The Rhinos became the first non-Major League Soccer team to win the U.S. Open Cup since the MLS came into the competition in 1996. The Rhinos put together an impressive run by knocking four MLS teams out the competition, including the defending Cup champion Chicago Fire, 1-0, in the third round.

Here is a complete list of upsets over Major League Soccer teams since 1996 ...
September 7, 1996 - Quarterfinals
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 4, Tampa Bay Mutiny (MLS) 3

October 12, 1996 - Semifinals
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 3, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 0

July 24, 1997 - Round of 16
San Francisco Bay Seals (D3) 2, Kansas City Wizards (MLS) 1

July 30, 1997 - Round of 16
Chicago Stingers (D3) 2, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 1

August 1, 1997 - Round of 16
Long Island Rough Riders (A-League) 4, New England Revolution (MLS) 3 (OT)

August 20, 1997 - Quarterfinals
San Francisco Bay Seals (D3) 2, San Jose Clash (MLS) 1

July 6, 1998 - Third Round
Nashville Metros (A-League) 3, Kansas City Wizards (MLS) 1

July 14, 1999 - Third Round
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 1, Chicago Fire (MLS) 0

August 4, 1999 - Third Round
Charleston Battery (A-League) 4, D.C. United (MLS) 3 (overtime)

August 11, 1999 - Quarterfinals
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 2, Dallas Burn (MLS) 1
(overtime)

September 1, 1999 - Semifinals
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 3, Columbus Crew (MLS) 2

September 14, 1999 - Final
Rochester Raging Rhinos (A-League) 2, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 0

June 14, 2000 - Second Round
Mid Michigan Bucks (PDL) 1, New England Revolution (MLS) 0

June 14, 2000 - Second Round
Chicago Sockers (PDL) 0, Kansas City Wizards (MLS) 0  (7:6 penalties)

June 14, 2000 - Second Round
Richmond Kickers (A-League) 3, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 0

June 26, 2001 - Second Round
Connecticut Wolves (A-League) 3, Tampa Bay Mutiny (MLS) 2

June 27, 2001 - Second Round
Charleston Battery (A-League) 4, MetroStars (MLS) 1

June 27, 2001 - Second Round
Seattle Sounders Select (PDL) 3, Dallas Burn (MLS) 2 (OT)

July 17, 2002 - Third Round
Milwaukee Rampage (A-League) 1, Chicago Fire (MLS) 0

August 5, 2003 - Fourth Round
Seattle Sounders (A-League) 1, San Jose Earthquakes (MLS) 0

August 6, 2003 - Fourth Round
Wilmington Hammerheads (USL-PSL) 4, Dallas Burn (MLS) 1

July 20, 2004 - Fourth Round
Charleston Battery (A-League) 1, MetroStars (MLS) 0

July 21, 2004 - Fourth Round
Richmond Kickers (A-League) 2, D.C. United (MLS) 1

July 13 - Third Round
Minnesota Thunder (USL-1) 6, Real Salt Lake (MLS) 4

USL - United Soccer League, PDL - Premier Development League, MLS - Major League Soccer, USL-PSL - United Soccer League-Premier Soccer League

About the U.S. Open Cup
The U.S. Open Cup, the national championship of the United States, began in 1914 and is the oldest annual team tournament in U.S. sports. Modeled after England's famous FA Cup, the Open Cup is open to all senior division teams, amateur and professional registered with the United States Soccer Federation (USSF).

The oldest trophy in the United States team sports  history was donated to the American Amateur Football Association in 1912 by Sir Thomas R. Dewar, a British distiller, sportsman and philanthropist during a AAFA (now known as United States Amateur Soccer Association) visit to London prior to the 1912 Olympics.

The trophy was originally purchased for $500 and given in the hope of promoting soccer in the United States and in the name of Anglo-American friendship. The cup was first awarded to the Yonkers Football Club (NY) in 1912 after they defeated the Hollywood Inn Football Club (NY) at the Lennox Oval in New York City. The trophy was officially adopted as the U.S. Open Cup trophy prior to the Brooklyn Field Club's inaugural championship in 1914 in Pawtucket, RI. The trophy was retired in 1979, but was refurbished by the USASA in 1997 and was presented to the 1997 and 1998 Open Cup winners, before permanently retiring to the National Soccer Hall of Fame in Oneonta, NY.

U.S. Open Cup History & Information
U.S. Open Cup History | U.S. Open Cup Champions | U.S. Open Cup Championship Results | 2005 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup | Most U.S. Open Cup Medal Winners

The great Bethlehem Steel teams appeared in six of the first seven finals, winning the trophy five times. In the the 1920's the competition was divided with an eastern and western final, with the winners meeting in the grand final. Teams from the professional American Soccer League (ASL) dominated, and in 1924 the ASL's Fall River Marksmen became the first to win the 'The Double' - the professional league championship and the U.S. Open Cup. In 1929, a record crowd of 20,000 packed Dexter Park in Brooklyn for the final between New York Hakoah SC and St. Louis Madison Kennel, with New York Hakoah SC winning the match 3-0.

Although it is now a single-elimination tournament, between 1928 and 1968 the U.S. Open Cup Final could be a two match (home and an away), or even a best-of-three. Regardless of the format, the competition lost its glamour over time, particularly when teams from the North American Soccer League (NASL) declined to participate. But in recent years, the U.S. Open Cup has returned to the public attention as teams from Major League Soccer (MLS) have vied for the historic trophy.

Monthly Column
This column is de
dicated to what is going on in and around the World of soccer today.

 About Us | Jobs | Mission Statement | Site Map | Contact Us | Links

All rights reserved. Use of the website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
© National Soccer Hall of Fame  18 Stadium Circle • Oneonta, New York • 13820 • (607) 432-3351
"Celebrating the History, Honoring the Heroes, Inspiring the Youth, and Preserving the Legacy of the sport of Soccer"